Saturday, March 6, 2010

Project Part 1 - sample output

Some of you wanted to verify whether the output of your code was correct. Here are some sample outputs that I got, and my assumptions. If you used different assumptions, you would get different results, but it doesn't mean that your results are wrong.

Assumptions:
TF value is not normalized
IDF value is not normalized
in the TF-based similarity, all query words are given equal weight
in the TF-IDF based similarity, the query words are weight by IDF alone, not (0.5 + 0.5*tf)*idf [slide 62]

TF-based similarity

query> fall semester
[22932]result3/www.asu.edu/registrar/general/semcal.html: 0.3900947488027469
[22978]result3/www.asu.edu/sbs/paying_semester_selection.html: 0.28127197523150593
[3765]result3/www.asu.edu/fs/advantage/com/308-12.htm: 0.27980420556019375
[14669]result3/www.asu.edu/lib/archives/archive.htm: 0.2644429426739725
[22980]result3/www.asu.edu/sbs/tuition_semester_selection.html: 0.25993762245501817
[871]result3/www.asu.edu/aad/manuals/usi/usi301-02.html: 0.2434322477800738
[991]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/nondegree/screen5.html: 0.23947373603569988
[1894]result3/www.asu.edu/clas/reesc/cli/yerevan2.htm: 0.23416772415725648

query> transcripts
[22956]result3/www.asu.edu/registrar/transcripts/index.html: 0.3460520089727601
[1055]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/steps/transcripts.html: 0.26490647141300877
[4145]result3/www.asu.edu/graduate/generalinfo/DeMund/index.html: 0.10283867552865913
[3930]result3/www.asu.edu/graduate/admissions/domestic.html: 0.10173145278829236
[16633]result3/www.asu.edu/lib/archives/shema/shema.htm: 0.09531918345647832
[3871]result3/www.asu.edu/graduate/SEM/admissions/requirements.htm: 0.08987062325802277
[22928]result3/www.asu.edu/registrar/general/contacts.html: 0.08728715609439695

query> admissions
[3759]result3/www.asu.edu/forms/index.html: 0.4375949744936837
[3758]result3/www.asu.edu/forms/forms_adm.htm: 0.41178049395232924
[964]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/international/index.html: 0.35909242322980395
[962]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/international/expenses.html: 0.33409177193234335
[936]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/contact/familymember.html: 0.31983816366946766
[22446]result3/www.asu.edu/provost/committees/FAS.html: 0.30983866769659335
[935]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/contact/counselor.html: 0.2950148263727627
[937]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/contact/freshman.html: 0.28966206101082875


TF-IDF based similarity:

query> fall semester
[22932]result3/www.asu.edu/registrar/general/semcal.html: 0.4359373503377644
[14669]result3/www.asu.edu/lib/archives/archive.htm: 0.2871305669297931
[991]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/nondegree/screen5.html: 0.27532125556740966
[22978]result3/www.asu.edu/sbs/paying_semester_selection.html: 0.26913921652871753
[22980]result3/www.asu.edu/sbs/tuition_semester_selection.html: 0.2601997953589357
[3765]result3/www.asu.edu/fs/advantage/com/308-12.htm: 0.24906102399484592

query> admissions
[3758]result3/www.asu.edu/forms/forms_adm.htm: 0.5744080507440753
[938]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/contact/index.html: 0.5031740605651273
[964]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/international/index.html: 0.43059540671762864
[936]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/contact/familymember.html: 0.4172350134375292
[963]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/international/faq.html: 0.40879880279063435
[962]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/international/expenses.html: 0.38631455298928125
[3759]result3/www.asu.edu/forms/index.html: 0.38614177431456176
[937]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/contact/freshman.html: 0.38147065345148296

query> transcripts
[22956]result3/www.asu.edu/registrar/transcripts/index.html: 0.5123337680008732
[1055]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/steps/transcripts.html: 0.47577601236762335
[3930]result3/www.asu.edu/graduate/admissions/domestic.html: 0.18180264245956912
[3871]result3/www.asu.edu/graduate/SEM/admissions/requirements.htm: 0.15646994303347006
[1051]result3/www.asu.edu/admissions/steps/printsteps.html: 0.1554359618428368
[3834]result3/www.asu.edu/graduate/SEM/8admiss.htm: 0.14754024695739043


Thanks and Regards,
Sushovan De

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.